Should libraries in developing nations rely
on donations and weeded books from developed nations? Do libraries only need
books?
When
deciding if libraries in developing nations should rely on weeded books from
developed nations, my first reaction was no because I was thinking about all
the books I weeded from the non-fiction collection in our school library. They
were dated, torn and inaccurate. Zell (2015) talks about this practice of “book
dumping” and talks about the need to monitor and evaluate donation programs (p.
3).
I think that
supporting organizations such as Book Aid International where the majority of the books are brand new would be more
valuable than donating unwanted books from our library. Book Aid International
partnered with the National Library of Uganda to launch Inspiring Readers
program in Uganda in 2017 and 2018 and is now working in Kenya, Cameroon,
Malawi and Sierra Leone as well. Each school received a Book Box Library, which
includes 1250 brand new fiction and non-fiction books at different levels as
well as money to purchase local books and support the training of teachers
(2019a, para. 2-3). In addition, each participating school is “linked to its local library which already has a Children’s Corner. The libraries act as hubs, providing
teachers with additional support, extra books and the expertise of a professional
librarian” (2019b, para. 3). Book Aid International suggests that as a
result of these programs, students were reading for pleasure and their comprehension
skills improved, students’ confidence and participation in class increased and
teachers were using these new books in their lessons (2019b, para. 4-6).
Books
for Schools in Rumuruti, Kenya,
Book Aid International
Although schools are given small
grants to purchase some books locally, the majority of the books donated by
Book Aid International are published in the UK and the United States. At least
Book Aid International is making some effort to ensure that specific needs are
met and support local publishing because other donation companies are not doing
this. Zell suggests that many book donation organizations “paint a worst-case
scenario, in order to justify these organizations’ continuing existence” (2015,
p. 14) and make false claims that there are “few or no publishers” in Africa
and a “lack of high-quality age-appropriate children’s books in local
languages” (p. 12). In contrast, he suggests the industry has “developed
steadily” and is making progress and these organizations should be
collaborating with local publishers to find or develop suitable books (2015, p.
12).
He goes on to suggests that “[w]hile the people behind library aid and book donation
programmes are probably convinced that their schemes are well intentioned and
meet an acute need, even the most well-intentioned programmes may sometimes
have unintended, potentially negative consequences, and may not adequately take
into account the cultural and infrastructure implications” (2015, p. 5). He
suggests that by donating so many books, these organizations may actually be
doing harm because receiving donated books is now the norm for many libraries
in parts of Africa and this has created a “culture of dependency” because
governments rely on the support and don’t support local libraries (2015, p. 43).
Zell suggests this support can also hurt local book publishers because they
can’t compete with the free books the libraries are receiving (2015, p. 18). Thus,
Zell talks reiterates the need to
monitor and evaluate donation programs and refers to the Book
Donations for Development document published in 2005 by UNESCO as “the most current
and the most comprehensive document to date to provide extensive guidelines for
‘correct giving’,” but he talks about how there isn’t much evidence to suggest
book donors are following the recommendations (2015, p. 20).
Zell also suggests that
organizations such as Worldreader
that focus on bringing e-books to classrooms and public libraries in Africa
face the same challenges, but are working to include books from African
publishers (2015, p. 40). As I read Zell’s article, I thought about how much my
daughter loves reading books with us each day. I can’t imagine not having
access to physical picture books to read, so I wondered if it’s still worth
sending weeded fiction books to developing nations, but based on what I’ve read
and considering the of shipping books overseas, I think I would be more likely
to support organizations like CODE.
CODE supports initiatives in Africa but also in Canada and in the Caribbean.
They support local publishing so students have access to relevant books and
they help raise money towards the cost of library furniture as well as books
and training for library staff.
Do mobile devices place a role in these
libraries? How can they assist their patrons in accessing more up to date
information?
While I am still not sure where I
stand in terms of book donation programs abroad, I am curious to learn more
about the role of mobile devices in allowing users to access more up to date
information as well as programs that work to expand access to the Internet in
developing countries. According to Kirkpatrick (2018), infrastructure to allow
developing regions of the world access to the Internet is not always in place
and even when connections are available, many people cannot afford devices or
accounts to access the Internet (p. 20). Although some organizations donate
digital devices, these may be useless if people cannot access the Internet.
I explored three different
programs, each offering different services.
1.) The Ideas Box
Libraries Without Borders works
to provide access to information to people living in camps or developing
countries around the world and started the Ideas Box in 2010. The Ideas Box is mobile, uses its own power source, and
consists of integrated furniture that can be setup in less than 20 minutes. It
typically consists of “a satellite internet connection, digital server, a power generator, 25
tablets and laptops, 6 HD cameras, 1 large HD screen, board games, arts and
crafts materials, hardcover and paperback books, and a stage for music and
theatre” (Libraries Without Borders, n.d., para. 4), although each box is customized
to meet the needs of people in France, the United States, Australia and
Senegal.
Ideas Box, Bibliothèques
San Frontières
2. The Kio Kit
BRCK Education takes Kio Kits to 17
countries around the world. The kit is basically a digital classroom in a box
consisting of “40 Kio tablets, a SupaBRCK, wireless tablet charging
and a hardened, water-resistant, lockable case” (2019, para. 1). These kits are
designed in Africa for students in Africa. The entire kit has one plug and can
last 8 hours once charged. It can also be run using solar power. The tablets
run on an Android operating system, consist of interactive books and videos as
well as educational games and can operate without Internet access.
Digital
Classroom in a Box, BRCK Education
3.) eGranary
If access to an Internet connection is an issue, the eGranary Digital Library or “The Internet in a Box” consists
of 35 million digital resources that can be accessed offline (WiderNet,
n.d., para. 1). The eGranary, founded in 2001, consists of one of three
options - a full sized server, a smaller server that can operate on battery or
solar power, or a USB drive that can convert a computer into a server (WiderNet,
n.d., para. 3). The eGranary has a built in search engine that allows the user
to browse just like we would on the Internet but it requires no Internet
connection. It contains over 2000 websites, which they have received permission
to share as well as books, textbooks, journals and videos. The servers are setup
in schools, universities, libraries and hospitals around the world. In
addition, users have the ability to create content. They can make websites with
the built in editor as well as upload content from cell phones and laptops
allowing them to share their knowledge (The WiderNet Project, 2015).
eGranary
Animation, The WiderNet Project
References
Book Aid
International. (2017, April 27). Books
for Schools in Rumuruti, Kenya [Video file]. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/venf_QGRCbY
Book
Aid International. (2019a). Inspiring
Readers. Retrieved from https://bookaid.org/what-we-do/supporting-education/inspiring-readers/
Book
Aid International. (2019b, February 14). Inspiring
Readers Uganda phase one report. Retrieved from https://bookaid.org/publications/2019/02/14/inspiring-readers-uganda-phase-one-report/
BRCK (2016,
August 22). Digital Classroom in a Box
[Video file]. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/djzVDh6qKPk
BRCK Education.
(2019). Hardware, Software and
Connectivity Tools to Enable Learning. Retrieved from https://www.brck.com/education/#
CODE. (2018). What We Do. Retrieved from https://code.ngo/what-we-do
The Grommet.
(2015, October 16). Library: The Heart of
a Community [Video file]. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/mfpUuYRdA6Y
Heavner,
Rachel. (2019, January 29). Working with Publishers to Build Lasting Change.
Retrieved from https://www.worldreader.org/blog/working-with-publishers-to-build-lasting-change/
Kirkpatrick,
Keith. (2018). Bringing the Internet to the (Developing) World. Communications of the ACM, 61 (7), pp.
20-21.
Libraries
Without Borders. (n.d.). Ideas Box.
Retrieved from https://www.librarieswithoutborders.org/ideasbox/#1472134509606-d56b9763-2877
The WiderNet
Project. (2015, May 12). eGranary
Animation [Video file]. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/i8I6BVRSD5c
WiderNet. (n.d.).
About the eGranary. Retrieved from https://www.widernet.org/egranary/about
Worldreader.
(2018). Our Library. Retrieved from https://www.worldreader.org/our-solution/library
Zell, Hans M. (2015). Book Donation Programmes
for Africa: Time for a Reappraisal? Part I: Book Donation Programmes in
English-speaking Africa. Journal of
SCOLMA (the UK Libraries and Archives Group on Africa), 127, pp. 1-109. Retrieved
from https://www.academia.edu/13165497/Book_Donation_Programmes_for_Africa_Time_for_a_Reappraisal_Part_I


